Suit Against Town Over Kingdom Hall Settled
Mediation session draws up agreement that makes neighbors, church happy; pre-site work pushes back construction to next spring.
It's been a long couple years for Bob and Donna Walles and their neighbors who fought tooth and nail against the construction of a Kingdom Hall in their residential neighborhood on Wire Road.
But Bob Walles said, for the most part, it's all's well that ends well.
Six months ago, the Walles filed a lawsuit against the town for how it handled the reversal of a decision against a special exception to build a Kingdom Hall on a residential road.
However, Walles said the case was settled during a mediation session in which a five-condition agreement was drawn up that resolved a couple of issues neighbors of the church had with its plan. The agreement also precluded the Walles from further pursuing a lawsuit against the town.
“We thought the whole way they (the ZBA) went about it was wrong,” Walles said.
The suit was between the town and the Walles, but the Jehovah's Witnesses filed for rights for intervention and were granted them, Walles said.
In the suit, Walles accused the board of secret meetings and being forced to make the decision “under duress,” which he said at the time clouded their judgement.
“I contend that the members of the Zoning Board, during non-public and illegal meetings with the Town Counsel and Town Attorney were told to grant the special exception, to mitigate the potential legal costs of defending the pending lawsuit brought against the town by the congregation,” Walles said in the suit.
The suit was never about the church, but rather the process, Walles said. But, when the church intervened, the Walleses knew it was going to become much more difficult.
“They told us in no uncertain terms that they would continue to pursue the project,” Walles said, pointing out how expensive a legal battle could become.
A mediation session was pulled together with the Walles, Town Attorney Matt Upton, Judge Robert Morrill, Assistant Planner Nancy Larsen and representatives form the Jehovah's witnesses. In addition to agreeing to drop the case without prejudice – meaning the Walles cannot refile the same or a similar suit – the Jehovah's Witnesses agreed to tweak the design plan at the church move the driveway a few feet to make it so the headlights of cars exiting the church splash more on the woods than the homes across the street, to add more landscaping where the driveway was planned for originally, to create a hotline for people to call to be put on a do not call list and to inform the congregation that turning around in local driveways is strictly prohibiting, Walles said.
Despite heavy controversy during the hearings for the project between 2012 and 2012, and a discord between neighbors and the church, Walles said he and others have come around to the project, especially after the mediation session.
“We sitting here with this decision because something went right,” Walles said, adding that he and some of his neighbors have become very friendly with Ron and Lynn Hansen. “The process worked.”
That said, Walles does plan to pursue filing an ethics complaint and asking the town's ethics committee to look into how the ZBA handle the process.
Hansen, a congregation elder, said he also felt good about the results of the mediation.
“I think the one thing that came out of the mediation was it was an opportunity to answer a lot of the questions and concerns,” Hansen said.
The town also agreed to repair some potholes on the street and trim back some trees that obscure the line of sight for some motorists.
However, due to a couple set backs, none of the work at the church is going to be until spring, Hansen said. At the time the project was approved by the planning board Fran Lapoint, an engineer for the Jehovah's Witness regional building committee, said it was possible they could begin work on the construction project this fall, but last week, Hansen said the project has been pushed to the spring for a couple reasons.
The regional building committee for the Jehovah's Witnesses is busy building a couple other Kingdom Halls in Claremont and South Royalton, Vt., Hansen said, and there were some town and state conditions to rectify first.
“If we'd completed things soon enough, we were hoping to have been able to do some site work this fall, which would have helped us hit the ground in the spring, but it just got away from us and like I said, we've got some other projects going on over in Claremont and up in South Royalton, Vermont,” Hansen said.
One of those state conditions, digging test holes on the property to check for the possibility of historical significance on the property in terms of potential for American Indian activity.
As of last week, about 20 percent of the test holes had been completed, Hansen said. He added that its pretty standard for a project like this. When a storm water protection grant with the EPA, Hansen said it triggered a submission of the plan to several groups around the state, including the New Hampshire Department of Historical Resources, who required the test holes.
“Because of New Hampshire's river system, there was a lot of Indian activity around the state,” Hansen said. He does not believe there will arise a problem at the site. The main effect of the test holes is that the building project is definitely on hold unit probably April or May, Hansen said.
A timeline from the eventual approval of the Kingdom Hall.
2010: The Jehovah's Witnesses approach the town's Zoning Board of Adjustment to seek a special exception to build a church on old farm land on the residential road.
Fall 2010: After impassioned pleas from abutters to prevent this project, the ZBA ruled in the fall of 2010 against the special exception, citing traffic and public nuisance concerns, among other things.
Early 2011: The congregation appealed the ruling and the ZBA denied the appeal so the congregation sued the town, charging the town's special exception process is unconstitutional in that it lets a board apply one set of rules to one group and a different set to another. It also charged, among other things, that the town treated the church differently than it would have another denomination, violating the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act.
Nov. 16, 2011: The ZBA reversed its decision against the congregation in a settlement that effectively granted the special exception the board initially denied and moved it on to the Planning Board. ZBA's Nov. 16 ruling to settle the lawsuit.
Jan. 25, 2012: The Walleses were also denied a rehearing by the ZBA. Following the meeting, Bob Walles said he would regroup and see what his options are. In accordance with town statutes, the Walleses had 30 days from the Jan. 25 meeting to appeal the ruling to the Superior Court.
Feb. 7, 2012: The Merrimack Planning Board gives conditional approval to the congregation to build the church.
Solomon Ruffo
6:08 am on Tuesday, September 25, 2012
Heads up!
These Jehovah's Witnesses kingdom Hall church construction adds volunteer (free labor) built tax free assets to the Watchtower society of New York portfolio.
In the course of any 90 day period the Watchtower corporation will sell for profit,as many of these Kingdom Halls as they build.giving the illusion of growth.
The Watchtower Society corporation has up to $200 billion in worldwide mostly tax free real estate assets.
That's religion....,the Catholic church is bigger and richer.
jack
12:15 am on Tuesday, November 20, 2012
That's just plain ridiculous. I would not expect them to sell this building in 90 days after building it. It is possible that they may sell a building that has issues like after a flood or something like that....
MMK_townie
7:40 am on Tuesday, September 25, 2012
If they come ringing my doorbell...I'll ask for them to help pay my taxes that they don't have to pay!!!
Solomon Ruffo
1:39 am on Wednesday, September 26, 2012
Watchtower no public charities
The Jehovah's Witnesses have NO significant 'disaster relief' only token measures. Ever seen it? Ever seen a Jehovah's Witness mission for the poor,soup kitchen,hospital,clinic,food pantry?....no way
Charles Finley
9:22 am on Wednesday, September 26, 2012
The primary way Jehovah's Witnesses help their fellow man is by teaching them how to live by God's standards and they show them from the Bible that God's Kingdom is the only real hope for mankind. They don't just feed a person by giving them a fish.... They teach them HOW to fish. - Matthew 6:33, 34.
Solomon Ruffo
11:22 am on Wednesday, September 26, 2012
Reply-Charles Finley-
All I can say is HUH???
Giving someone Watchtower propaganda and thumping a Bible verse is not public charity.
James 1:20 "look after widows and orphans in their need,for this is the FIRST commandment,"
Think!
jack
12:07 am on Tuesday, November 20, 2012
oddly you seem to imply that they are the only people who don't pay taxes... I am not aware of any religion paying taxes, not to mention the host of Non Profit sector. This would be not an issue about any one religion but something our government has setup for the nonprofit sector.
g morris
9:12 am on Tuesday, September 25, 2012
Good that the Welles came to an "ammicable" settlement although from a legal standpoint, agreeing to set up a hotline to register do not call requests as a condition to exist is to say the least bizarre! as that would have to be a standard that would apply to every church in the United States including the one attended by opponents of this project. It would not survive for a minute in court if non compliance were challenged.
David Pine
9:29 am on Tuesday, September 25, 2012
Jw.org
Dyno Darlene
9:41 am on Tuesday, September 25, 2012
Cold calling can become criminal TRESPASSING
Jehovah's Witnesses have a sales subterfuge where they do "ask for donations" when "dispensing" literature this is a round-about-way of selling.
They don't have to register with the town and get a solicitation permit that's the deal with Jehovah's Witnesses.A man/woman home is their castle,and trespassing after notice not to enter becomes defiant trespassing and is another matter.
Like with Scientology religion (who don't go door to door) there are many former member rebuttal sites on line my favorite is: jwfacts(dot)com
jack
12:09 am on Tuesday, November 20, 2012
this you are wrong about... sorry to say...http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/scripts/getcase.pl?navby=CASE&court=US&vol=536&page=150
g morris
11:12 am on Tuesday, September 25, 2012
Jehovah's Wittnesses do NOT solicit donations as they visit people, contrary to previous posts by determined misinformers. Any ivestigation by an interested party will be able to prove it to themselves. How the activities of Jehovah's Wittnesses are financed is clearly stated and stictly adhered to on their website. http://www.jw.org/en/jehovahs-witnesses/faq/work-financed/ if it were not, should we suppose for one minute that opposers would waste any time at all persuing legal channels. They do not because there is nothing to persue. It is enevitable that ex JW's will attempt to misinform the uninformed. However a truly shrewd person will not be misled.
Solomon Ruffo
12:06 pm on Tuesday, September 25, 2012
Jehovah's Witnesses are not just "another religion".
They use deception and coercive tactics much like hard core cults except worse they come on your door step and talk to your family.
If they minded their own in a compound somewhere I would be silent about it.
John
12:23 am on Friday, September 28, 2012
No, you're the misinformer here. JWs are the biggest liars on the internet, I've noticed. From your own literature, the Kingdom Ministry of Jan 2006:
**Ways to Mention the Donation Arrangement**
“If you would like to make a small donation today toward our worldwide work, I will gladly accept it.”
“Although our literature is offered without charge, we do accept modest donations for our worldwide work.”
“You may wonder how we can afford to do this work. It is because our worldwide work is supported by voluntary donations. If you wish to make a small donation today, I will be pleased to accept it.”
-----
And
"Our Kingdom Ministry" October 2009:
10 min: Prepare to Offer The Watchtower and Awake! Talk. Review the contents of the current magazines, and highlight which articles may be of interest in the local territory. Include one demonstration in which a parent helps a child to prepare for the ministry. The parent and child select an article, develop a question, and choose a scripture to use. The child then demonstrates his presentation, MENTIONING THE DONATION ARRANGEMENT.
Stop lying.
Adina Hope
11:52 am on Tuesday, September 25, 2012
Jehovah's Witnesses DO ask for money (donations) and everybody knows it.They ask me nearly every time.
No problem there ...except to deny it creates a trust issue,The reason Jehovah's Witnesses call 'to encourage bible reading' is also deceptive.You are their to recruit disciples plain and simple
Mikey Ridley
10:55 pm on Tuesday, September 25, 2012
How do people come up with such wrong information, The internet ? Jehovah's witness own their own Kingdom halls. The one here will be built with local contributions from the local members. If they get a loan, sometimes with banks or other lending institution they make the payments. The parent Watch Tower does make some loans but not always. Yes the labor is free .materials are not. Who cares
that they get free labor. I built my own house so I got free labor. Whats wrong with that. If all the members decided to build and sell they could. I am a realtor and I have handled sells of halls before.